| Ellwood Chappell | Nebraska '16 | Justice Nebraska State Supreme Court 1943- |
| Kenneth Chantry | Stanford '26 | Los Angeles Superior Court |
| Howard Ameli | NYU '05 | Lawyer, member of Tiger Inn - the top eating club at Princeton |
| Norris Bakke | Chicago '19 | Former Supreme Court Justice, Colorado |
| Winfield Bardwell | Minnesota '04 | Judge, member of Theta Delta Chi |
| Calvin Barry | Windsor '8019s | Ontario District Crown Attorney |
| Bruce Blake | Michigan '05 | Former Supreme Court Justice, Washington |
| Fletcher Brown | USC '11 | Former Supreme Court Justice, California |
| James Cammack Jr. | Kentucky, '24 | Former Court of Appeals Chief Justice, Kentucky |
| Arthur Cathcart | Stanford 1896 | Professor of Law, member of Delta Upsilon |
| William Christianson | Chicago '20 | Supreme Court of Minnesota, judge at the Nuremberg trials |
| Sidney Clunis | Osgoode Hall '35 | First Judge called to the Bar of Ontario under Monarch King Edward VII |
| Clarence Craig | USC '11 | Former Superior Court Justice, California |
| Harley Crosby | Cornell 1897 | Supreme Court of the state of New York |
| John Deane | Osgoode Hall '6019s | IBM Canada's former lawyer |
| Cyrus Dietz | Northwestern '02 | Former Supreme Court Justice, Illinois |
| Edward Eberle | Osgoode Hall '55 | Justice - Supreme Court of Ontario |
| Charles Elliot | Minnesota | Former Supreme Court Justice, Minnesota |
| Glenn Fairbrook | Washington '14 | Former President, Washington State Bar Association |
| Carlton Fisher | NYU '21 | Former Supreme Court Justice, New York |
| Henry Fletcher | Minnesota '03 | Professor of Law |
| Frank Ford | Osgoode Hall 1895 | Former Justice of Appeal, Alberta Surpreme Court |
| Patrick Galligan | Osgoode Hall '50 | Justice - Supreme Court of Ontario |
| James Gordon Jr. | Pennsylvania '10 | Former Judge, Pennsylvania |
| Albert Haight | Buffalo (ASC) | Former Court of Appeals Justice, New York |
| Edward Hatch | Buffalo | Former Supreme Court Justice, New York |
| Edwin Jaggard | Minnesota | Former Supreme Court Justice, Minnesota |
| Harold Kelly | Buffalo '27 | Supreme Court for the eighth judicial district of New York |
| Daniel Kenefick | Buffalo | Former Supreme Court Justice, New York |
| Harry Lamson | Buffalo '00 | Former Associate Judge of the City Court, Buffalo |
| Arthur LaPrade | Stanford '42 | Former Chief Justice, Arizona Supreme Court, Former Attorney General of Arizona |
| Charles Loring | Minnesota 1898 | Former Chief Justice, Minnesota Supreme Court |
| Hall Lusk | Georgetown '07 | Former Chief Justice Oregon Supreme Court |
| Almon Lytle | Buffalo '03 | Former Supreme Court Justice, New York |
| Malcolm MacDonald | Osgoode Hall '05 | Chief Justice of the Supreme Court of British Columbia |
| Carl Maher | Michigan '07 | Former District Justice, Iowa |
| John Moore | Osgoode Hall '06 | Former Senior Justice of the County Court Ontario |
| Thomas Nash | Texas '24 | County Judge of Dallas County, Texas |
| John Park | Michigan 1893 | Former Circuit Court Justice, Missouri |
| Charles Plaxton | Osgoode Hall '13 | Supreme Court of Ontario |
| C.F. Rathbun | Chicago-Kent '04 | Former Special District Attorney Chicago |
| Frank Rathje | NW '07 | President of the American Bar Association |
| Daniel Reed | Cornell '1898 | Lawyer in Dunkirk, New York, 1900-1903, attorney for New York State Excise Department, 1903-1907, football coach at Cornell University, 1909-1918, member, Special Food Conservation Mission to France and England, 1918-1919, member of Congress, 43rd New York District, 1919-1959, member House Ways and Means Committee, 1933-1959, chairman, 1953-1954, chairman of Subcommittee on Social Security, 1948, and delegate to Interparliamentary Union, 1938, 1948-1950, 1952. |
| B.K. Roberts | Florida '28 | Former Supreme Court Justice, Florida |
| Matthew Rosenbaum | Hobart '86 | Supreme Court justice for the Seventh Judicial District of New York State |
| Robert Rutherford | Osgoode Halll '50 | Justice-Supreme Court of Ontario |
| Gordon Simpson | Texas '15 | Texas Supreme Court |
| Frank Smith | Pennsylvania '08 | President Judge and Judge of the Court of Common Pleas in Philadelphia |
| Gordon Thompson | Southern California '51 | Chief Judge - US District Court |
| Ira Thompson | Abracadabra '09 | Former Supreme Court Justice, California |
| Robert Vance | Alabama '50 | Judge - US Court of Appeals |
| Dalton Wells | Osgoode Hall '22 | Former Supreme Court Justice, Ontario Court of Appeals |
| Herman Wells | | |
| Myron Westover | Michigan 1895 | Former Superior Court Justice, California |
| Thomas White | Southern California '11 | Former Supreme Court Justice, California |
| Hon. James Wilkerson | DePauw 1889 | Former Federal District Judge, Sentenced Al Capone, Former State Representative Illinois |
