| Frank "Dutch" Sommer | Penn '10 | Head football coach - Michigan State |
| Fred Abel | Washington '25 | Former Professional Football Player (Milwaukee Badgers, 1926) |
| Francis Andrews | Penn State '36 | NCAA Football Player |
| Bob Anton | Indiana '41 | NCAA Wrestling champion in 128 pound division |
| Frederick Asbeck | Michigan '29 | Professional Baseball Player |
| Bruno Banducci | Stanford '43 | Former NFL player |
| Jack Barbee | Idaho '35 | NCAA Football Player |
| George Bateman | DePauw '36 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Les Belding | Iowa '22 | Professional Football Player (Rock Island Independents, 1925) |
| Cheevers Berry | Georgetown '04 | Former Football Coach, University of North Carolina |
| Richard Beyer | Cornell '33 | Former Football Coach, Cornell University |
| Harry Bomers Jr. | Michigan State '60 | Commissioner of the North American Basketball League |
| George Boos | Minnesota '27 | Professional Hockey Player |
| Lynden Bowring | Southern California '12 | Yachtsman |
| Jim Browning | Michigan State '60 | Olympic skater |
| John Burns | Eastern Illinois '69 | Pro Baseball Player - Atlanta Braves |
| Robert Campbell | Indiana '68 | All-American wrestler |
| R. Campbell | Penn State '30 | Intercollegiate wrestling champion |
| Jack Clark | Florida '37 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| John Clinnin | Chicago-Kent '11 | Former President National Boxing Association |
| Alfred Cobb | Syracuse '17 | Professional Football Player (Akron Pros, Cleveland Bulldogs) |
| Clyde Coffman | Kansas '33 | Member of 1932 Olympic Track Team |
| Jerry Colangelo | Kansas '61 | NCAA Basketball Player |
| Marion Coltrin | Arizona '37 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| John Cooper | Idaho | NCAA Football Player |
| Joe Cormier | Southern California '86 | Professional Football Player (Los Angeles Raiders, 1987) |
| Craig Craig | Florida '56 | All-American swimmer (diving) |
| John Dagenhard | Ohio State '39 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| Jonathan Daniels | Cornell '99 | General Manager for the Texas Rangers baseball team |
| Norberto Davidds-Garrido | USC '96 | Pro Football Player |
| Richard Davis | Indiana '37 | NCAA Football Player |
| Larry Davis | Arizona '36 | NCAA Track Star |
| Tommy Deckard | Indiana '38 | Track star, Olympic team in 1936, world record in stepplechase |
| Rod Dedeaux | | Former USC coach and college baseball's "Coach of the Century" |
| Jack DelRio | USC '85 | Former NFL player and current coach |
| Victor Dorris | Ohio State '38 | Former Head Coach and Director of Football at Ohio State University |
| John Drish | Illinois '41 | Former Professional Basketball Player |
| Chris Ello | San Diego '83 | Sports radio personality |
| Conner Emerson | Texas '31 | Former Pro Football Player |
| Joel Evans | Southern California '36 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Walter Evers | Illinois '42 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| Arthur Fowler | Alabama '41 | Golden Gloves Boxing Champion |
| John "Chick" Fox | Southern Cal '20 | Captain of the football team in 1917 |
| Raleigh Francis | Oklahoma | NCAA Football Player |
| Ben Franklin | Southern Cal '36 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Ivan Fuqua | Indiana '34 | NCAA Track Star: held 500-yard dash world record, member of the 1932 Olympic Team |
| Benny Garcia | Arizona State '56 | US Olympic Team - Javelin |
| Bruce Gardner | Southern California '60 | All-American Baseball Player |
| Don Gaskill | USC | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Richard Genovese | Illinois '67 | US Luge Champion |
| Martin Gentry | Arizona | Captain of the football team in 1927 |
| Homer Geoffrion | Cornell '35 | Captain of the lacrosse team |
| Pat Gillick | Southern Cal '58 | General Manager for the Philadelphia Phillies |
| Byron Goodridge | Arizona | NCAA Baseball Player |
| John Grover | Washington U. '08 | President of the Missouri Valley A.A.U. |
| Kent Hadley | Southern California '56 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| Joseph Hagan | Kentucky '38 | Captain of the football team |
| Bill Harding | Stanford '32 | 1932 US Olympic Rifle Team |
| Homer Hargiss | Kansas (FAC) | Former Track Coach University of Kansas |
| Nolan Harrison | Indiana '90 | NFL Hall of Fame Member |
| Brian Hayward | Cornell '82 | Former NHL goalie, Broadcaster for Disney Sports Enterprises |
| Bill Heath | Southern California '61 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| John Heldt | Iowa '22 | Professional Football Player (Coumbus Tigers) |
| Larry Himes | Southern California '64 | Former General Manager for the Chicago Cubs |
| W.B. Himrod | Southern California '11 | Track and Field Star |
| Darrell Holman | Stanford '37 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| John Houser | Alabama '35 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| James Hucker | Cornell '37 | Track Star |
| Harry Huff | Kansas '09 | Former Track Coach, University of Missouri |
| Tom Joaquin | Stanford '28 | Championship in javelin throw |
| Chuck Kassel | Illinois | Former Professional Football Player |
| Robert Kessler | Purdue '36 | NCAA Basketball Player, captain of the Purdue team |
| Rolland Kurtz | Purdue '33 | Heavyweight Golden Gloves boxing champion in 1932 |
| Don Lash | Indiana '37 | Sullivan Memorial Award Winner in 1938, NCAA cross country and track star, 12 national titles, |
| Don Lee | Arizona '56 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| Hardie Lewis | Oklahoma '33 | NCAA wrestling champion |
| Raymond Lloyd | Valdosta '90 | Professional Wrestler with World Championship Wrestling as "Glacier" |
| Frank Lubin | UCLA '31 | Former All-American and Olympic Games Basketball Player |
| Clyde Lyle | Purdue '29 | Member of the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame |
| Frank Mallette | Southern California | All-American football |
| Paul McFarland | DePauw '36 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Dan McMullen | Nebraska '29 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Ron Mix | Southern California '60 | NFL Hall of Fame Member |
| James Moore | Idaho | NCAA Football Player |
| Jim Morris | Arizona '34 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Guy Morton | Alabama '53 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| James Murphy | Northwest Missouri '86 | NY Giants Player |
| Harold Nichols | Iowa State FAC | 1939 NCAA Wrestling Champion, wrestling Hall of Fame |
| Leo Nomellini | Minnesota '50 | NFL Hall of Fame Member |
| Larry Olsonoski | Minnesota '48 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Frank O'Neill | Syracuse '04 | Football coach at Colgate and Rutgers |
| William Owens | Stanford '14 | President of the NCAA |
| Paul Pardonner | Purdue '34 | Former Pro Football Player |
| Simon Pauxtis | Pennsylvania '10 | Former Professional Football Player, All-America Football Player |
| Stonko Pavko | Idaho '38 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Boni Petcoff | Ohio State '24 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Walt Peterson | Southern California '65 | NCAA Baseball Player |
| Ted Petoskey | Michigan '32 | Former Football All-American |
| Harold Petz | Nebraska '32 | All-American in Track |
| Bill Pidto | Cornell '87 | Sports commentator |
| Frank Piekarski | Pennsylvania '05 | Former Football All-American |
| Raymond Pierce | Kansas '26 | Professional Baseball Player |
| Lee Pitlock | Southern Illinois '69 | Drafted to play Pro Baseball - San Francisco Giants |
| Hamp Pool | Stanford '40 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Shshriar Pourdanesh | Reno '93 | Former Pro Football Player |
| La Verle Pratt | Idaho '67 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Marshall Reynolds | Pennsylvania '05 | Former Football All-American |
| Don Ritter | Indiana '46 | Former Professional Basketball Player |
| Samuel Robertson | Buffalo 1897 | President of the Buffalo Bison baseball club in the International League |
| Sanford Rodgers | Arizona '67 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Italo Rossi | Purdue '42 | Former Professional Football Player |
| John Rudometkin | Southern California '62 | Former Professional Basketball Player |
| Vernon Rulison | DePauw '37 | NCAA Football Player |
| Sean Salisbury | Southern Californi '85 | Former NFL player and ESPN analyst |
| Wayne Sandefur | Purdue '36 | NCAA Football Player |
| Tom Satriano | Southern California '62 | Former Professional Baseball Player |
| Oliver Savatsky | Miami (OH) '35 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Otto Schnellbacher | Kansas '45 | Former All-American Football Player at the University of Kansas, All-Conference Basketball Player at the University of Kansas, Former Professional Football Player (New York Giants) and Basketball Player, member of University of Kansas Sports Hall of Fame and Kansas Sports Hall of Fame, Served in the military 1944-45 |
| Nick Sebek | Indiana '50 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Garland Shepherd | Stanford '10 | Intercollegiate high jump record |
| Sylvester Shonka | Nebraska '11 | All American Football Player |
| Mike Siwek | Western Michigan '70 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Bronko Smilanich | Arizona 40 | Former Professional Football Player |
| David Smith | Mississippi State '68 | All-American skeet, NSSA World Champion |
| Henry Stanton | Arizona '42 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Alex Stepanovich | Ohio State '04 | Former OSU football star, NFL player |
| Scott Studwell | Illinois '76 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Charles Taylor | Stanford ' 43 | Football All-American |
| Billy Thom | Iowa '23 | World light-heavy weight champion, coach of Olympic team in 1936 |
| Donald Thorp | Illinois '86 | Chicago Bears Player |
| Don Thorp | Illinois '85 | Former Professional Football Player |
| John Tobin | Chicago '05 | Former Football Coach, Tulane University |
| Dick Tomlinson | Kansas 50 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Don Tonry | Illinois '59 | Won NCAA all-around best gymnast |
| Arnold Umbach | Auburn (Faculty) | Wrestling Coach at Auburn for 27 years, Hall of Fame Member |
| Kyle Wachholtz | Soutern California '96 | Professional Football Player |
| Lawrie Wallace | Osgoode Hall '24 | Member of Canada's 1924 Olympic rowing team |
| Harrison Weeks | Michigan '02 | All American Football Player |
| Rick Welts | Washington '75 | President and COO, Phoenix Suns (NBA) |
| Harold Wheeler | Purdue '28 | Member of the Indiana Basketball Hall of Fame |
| Robert White | Indiana '43 | Captain of football team |
| Dave Whitsell | Indiana '58 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Charles Wilson | Idaho '35 | NCAA Football Player |
| Fred Wilt | Indiana '43 | Sullivan Memorial Award in 1950, Indiana University Hall of Fame and the National Track & Field Hall of Fame, Olympic Runner |
| Dennis Wirgowski | Purdue '71 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Casmir Witucki | Indiana '50 | Former Professional Football Player |
| Gus Zarnas | Ohio State '38 | All American Football Player |
| Lloyd Schiller | Idaho '52 | |